Ebook Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young
Exactly how can? Do you assume that you do not need sufficient time to choose purchasing e-book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young Don't bother! Simply rest on your seat. Open your kitchen appliance or computer and be on-line. You could open or see the web link download that we provided to obtain this Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young By by doing this, you can obtain the on the internet book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young Checking out guide Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young by on the internet can be truly done conveniently by conserving it in your computer and also gadget. So, you can proceed whenever you have leisure time.
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young
Ebook Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young
Reviewing a publication Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young is sort of simple task to do whenever you desire. Even reading every time you want, this task will certainly not disturb your various other tasks; lots of people generally review guides Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young when they are having the extra time. Exactly what about you? Exactly what do you do when having the leisure? Don't you invest for pointless points? This is why you need to obtain guide Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young and aim to have reading routine. Reading this e-book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young will not make you useless. It will certainly offer more advantages.
Obtaining the books Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young now is not type of difficult means. You can not just opting for book shop or library or borrowing from your close friends to read them. This is a quite simple method to precisely obtain guide by on-line. This on-line e-book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young can be one of the alternatives to accompany you when having downtime. It will not lose your time. Think me, the book will show you brand-new thing to review. Merely spend little time to open this on the internet book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young and read them wherever you are now.
Sooner you get guide Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young, quicker you can delight in reviewing guide. It will be your resort to maintain downloading and install the publication Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young in supplied web link. In this means, you could truly making a decision that is worked in to obtain your personal publication online. Below, be the initial to obtain guide entitled Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young as well as be the initial to understand just how the author implies the notification as well as expertise for you.
It will have no uncertainty when you are visiting choose this book. This inspiring Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young book could be checked out totally in particular time relying on how typically you open as well as review them. One to bear in mind is that every book has their very own production to obtain by each viewers. So, be the great viewers and be a much better person after reading this e-book Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, By Marilyn Young
The first book to give equal weight to the Vietnamese and American sides of the Vietnam war.
- Sales Rank: #361145 in eBooks
- Published on: 2015-02-03
- Released on: 2015-02-03
- Format: Kindle eBook
From Publishers Weekly
In this dark account of the political and diplomatic sides of the Vietnam wars and the psychic aftermath, the author contends that the Indochina experience refuted (temporarily) the simplistic assumptions that in foreign policy America always "meant well" and that communism was always "bad." The epithets popularly employed to characterize the enemy in Vietnam--"indifferent to human life," "dishonest," "ruthless"--came to characterize our own actions as well. From counterinsurgency expert Edward Lansdale's "cheerful brutalization of democratic values" to President Nixon's attempt to "make war look like peace," the moral breakdown is assessed here in disturbing detail. Young goes on to argue that more recent U.S. intervention in Lebanon, Libya, Grenada and Panama suggests that few lessons were learned in Vietnam--indeed, that the past decade has seen a dangerous resurgence of native faith in the benevolence of American foreign meddling. This, she maintains, goes hand in hand with a renewed commitment to use force in a global crusade against Third World revolutions and governments. Young, a history professor at New York University, paints a grim picture of our part in the Indochina war and its excoriating effects on the nation. Photos.
Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Two new books join the many which try to summarize and analyze the Vietnam War, its precedents, and its epilog, with differing approaches and results. Young (history, NYU) coauthored, along with William G. Rosenberg, Transforming Russia & China ( LJ 1/1/82). Her current study focuses on the American experience, while touching on the periods before and after direct American involvement. She provides some useful insights, and details debates among American leaders, but she draws predominantly on published sources and offers little new information. More significantly, her arguments are heavily biased (she seems to think that only the American and South Vietnamese military and governments demonstrated cruelty, corruption, deception, and destruction), leading to some troubling conclusions (e.g., that U.S. bombing of Cambodia may have been responsible for the later horrors of the Khmer Rouge), and leaving the reader unable to place events in any kind of valid historical perspective. In stark contrast to Young's black-and-white picture, Olson and Roberts (history, Sam Houston State Univ. and Purdue Univ., respectively) paint a picture of many colors. This successful popular history of the war is less scholarly, less detailed than The Vietnam Wars , but the better-balanced coverage throughout yields a more insightful, instructive history. At times the authors' emotionalism (e.g., the account of the My Lai massacre) clouds their presentation, and the otherwise fascinating discussion of the postwar media's depiction of the war is not up to date, but general readers will find their book to be a helpful and accessible introduction to the complexities of the Vietnam experience.
- Kenneth W. Berger, Duke Univ. Lib., Durham, N.C.
Copyright 1990 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
"This story "The Vietnam Wars, " this terrible history is told with such clarity and passion, detail, intelligence it's hard to stop reading. The tension in the writing keeps your sadness in some kind of check as you read about opportunities for peace lost again and again, and think of today's newspapers and how we are, with some differences, modification, and more firepower, once again half the world away confusing credibility with honor." -- Grace Paley"It is a marvelously wide-ranging and lively synthesis--unmatched in its striking juxtaposition of the Vietnamese revolution with American (old War policy and ideology and in its sensitivity to the human dimensions of the conflict on both sides. This engaged and engaging study deserves a place at the top of everyone's Vietnam reading list." -- Michael H. Hunt, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill"Eloquent . . . A concise and effective exposition of the events of the war, and a cogent analysis of the motives underlying America's decision to make war against Vietnam.'"-- "Kirkus Reviews ""A first-rate synthesis of the vast literature on the Vietnam War which effectively interweaves U.S. involvement in Indochina with relevant developments on the American domestic front in a way that makes both more understandable."-- George McT. Kahin, Cornell University"This is the history of the war in Vietnam we have been waiting for. This is a marvelous achievement--meticulously documented, excitingly narrated, written with grace, wit, and passion."-- Howard Zinn
Most helpful customer reviews
35 of 45 people found the following review helpful.
A good (but biased) popular history
By Urobolos
You'll notice that the reviews posted so far for Marilyn Young's "Vietnam Wars" are quite polarized (1 star vs. 5 stars). Some complain of Young's agenda and anti-American viewpoint, while others find her tone appropriate and the book revealing; all of these points are valid. This book is biased, frustratingly so at times, but it is also informative and a good read.
"Vietnam Wars" covers the Vietnamese struggle for independence from France, the war with the US, and the war with China, naturally focusing on the American war. The substance of the book is a mix of details of the actual war and the politics concerning it, with ample, though not exhaustive, footnotes and plenty of fascinating anecdotes. The level of detail is perfect for a popular history.
The tone of the book is distinctly anti-American, partly because of the author's own bias, but also partly because of the information available. The details of North Vietnam's motivations, actions, etc. are lacking, I imagine because there are so few sources. As a result, the viewpoint is American, and the mistakes made by the US are on full display; I found these to be the most interesting aspects of the war, e.g., the astounding naiveness of Psy Ops.
The author's bias is irritating, though thankfully clear. While she does not engage in outright revisionism (her facts are supported by references), she does selectively emphasize information. For example, while civilian deaths inflicted by US firepower are mentioned repeatedly, over many pages, atrocities commited by the North are downplayed, in oneliners along the lines of "Only 15-thousand Vietnamese civilians were executed by the VC, not 500-thousand, as claimed in US propaganda!". Despite this selectivity, sufficient facts are presented to convey the moral ambiguity that surrounds the conflict.
Read skeptically, Marilyn Young's "Vietnam Wars" is an excellent starting point for understanding Vietnam.
20 of 25 people found the following review helpful.
The Herioc-Tragedy of Vietnam
By A Customer
Herein lies the terrible tragedy of Vietnam. Marilyn Young covers the First Indochina War, through the Second (the Vietnam War to Americans), and the Third. Written mostly from the American and foreign point of view, she narrates the events as they occurred without rancor or judgment or obvious bias. Yet one gets the distinct feeling that this account is anti-American, but how else could it be? The facts she lays out with no value judgment, messy opinions, or biased reporting unerringly points to the mistakes and false assumptions that America had about Vietnam. How these mistakes lead to the tragic war, a senseless war, that laid waste to an entire nation.
There is a famous saying in Vietnam, "At no time has Vietnam lacked heroes." The unsaid, but implicit understanding is that at no time has Vietnam lacked aggressors. What America at the time could not realize was that she was following in the footsteps of previous conquerors in Vietnam's past. America, though filled with good intentions, was simply another in a long line of overwhelming enemies like China, the Mongols, France, and Japan. In all honesty, at certain points I could not help laughing out loud. Not in amusement, but at the sheer, overwhelming stupidity and arrogance that compounded mistake after mistake by the foreign powers and every chance for peace was dashed because of Cold War politics and ignorance. France, the once mighty empire, was now an impotent, senile power that still clung to the trappings of imperial might. And the U.S., caught up in the Red Scare, failed to realize that the growth of Communism in Vietnam was an outgrowth of nationalism against imperialistic powers like France. To the U.S., it was a fight against Communism. To the average Vietnamese peasant, it was a war, in a long line of wars, for freedom.
I think that this is definitely a good book to read to familiarize oneself with the wars that Vietnam has fought. Though it covers all three of the Indochina wars, it only moderate covers the first, glosses over the last, and mostly details the second from the American perspective. In this area, I find the book is lacking because while it accurately describes what, how, and why the Americans did what they did, she did not pay enough attention to the first half of the equation, the Vietnamese. A fuller appreciation and understanding of the events would require us to have an accounting from the Vietnamese perspective, from Hanoi, to the average bo dai (grunt), and the peasant. It also is rather lacking in details and events that occurred during World War II and the Japanese occupation. Still, the harsh and unrelenting look that it gives us of American policy, practice, and presidents coupled with an easy to read yet grippingly eloquent prose makes this a book a must have for anyone wanting to better understand Vietnam and her wars for freedom.
21 of 28 people found the following review helpful.
Hubris: America in Veitnam
By Robert A. Kolinski
It is rare that I will read a book twice, but Marilyn B. Young's history of American involvement in Vietnam is so packed with information and so clearly written, that I recently felt compelled to read it once again. It plots, very logically, how America went down the slippery slope that was Veitnam. Our foreign policy towards Vietnam was based on a culture never understood, and assumptions never questioned. I've read a dozen books on Vietnam in the past ten years, and this is by far the best.
See all 35 customer reviews...
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young PDF
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young EPub
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young Doc
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young iBooks
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young rtf
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young Mobipocket
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young Kindle
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young PDF
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young PDF
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young PDF
Vietnam Wars 1945-1990, by Marilyn Young PDF
